Website of Author Steve McIntosh, Integral Philosopher and Social Entrepreneur
  • Home
  • Books
    • The Presence of the Infinite
      • Overview
      • Table of Contents
      • Introduction
      • Chapter 5
      • Chapter 6
    • Evolution’s Purpose
      • Overview
      • Table of Contents
      • Preface
      • Chapter Two
      • Chapter Six
      • Chapter Seven
      • Chapter Nine
    • Integral Consciousness
      • Overview
      • Table of Contents
      • Chapter One
      • Chapter Two
      • Chapter Three
      • Chapter Four
      • Chapter Five
      • Chapter Six
  • Blog
  • Author Bio
    • Short Bio
    • Long Bio
    • Photographs
  • Videos
    • Presence of the Infinite Book Talk
    • Evolution’s Purpose Book Talk
    • Other Videos
      • The Spiritual Teachings of Evolution
      • Andrew Cohen Interview
      • TED-Style Talk
      • Salzman Interview
      • Think Tank Presentation
  • Articles
    • Growing Out of America’s Divided Culture
    • Appreciating the Upside of Nationalism
    • Why Centrism Fails
    • Overcoming Polarization by Evolving Right and Left
    • Depolarizing the American Mind
    • Fostering Evolution in Islamic Culture
    • Climate Change Amelioration Plan
    • Premises and Principles of the Evolutionary Worldview
    • Integral Politics Comes of Age
    • Integral Politics, Tikkun
    • Problemitizing Interobjectivity
  • Media
    • Interviews
    • Media on The Presence of the Infinite
    • Media on Evolution’s Purpose
    • Media on Integral Consciousness
  • Think Tank
  • Public Teaching

Hyper-Partisan Polarization is More of a Cultural Problem than a Political One

Posted on November 9, 2018 by Steve McIntosh in Uncategorized

Here’s my latest blog, which is reposted from the Institute for Cultural Evolution’s website:

The 2018 midterm results are in. And despite two years of creative destruction, consistent anti-environmental policy moves, and the moral degradation of the office of the presidency, Trumpism has not been thoroughly repudiated by America’s voters. Democrats gained a House majority, but it looks like Republicans have locked up the Senate through 2022 at least. Which means that, barring a major political upheaval, hyper-partisan polarization is here to stay.

In the post-election pundit-sphere, talk of criminal justice reform and a possible infrastructure bill provide rays of hope for bipartisan compromise. But the potential for meaningful progress on even these relatively small and sensible issues remains unlikely because of the extreme bitterness that characterizes our divided political duopoly. This bitterness was reflected by CNN commentator Van Jones, who expressed hope for progress on these issues, but then added the sentiment that “most progressives don’t want to work with a lying racist or give him any legislative victories.”

Meanwhile, the post-election editorial stance of Real Clear Politics was reflected in an op-ed by centrist party proponent Nick Troiano, who wrote:

“National leaders must come together to catalyze the ‘Exhausted Majority’ of Democrats, Republicans, and independents into a new, grassroots ‘Country Over Party’ movement as powerful as those on the left and right.”

While I applaud this call to “come together,” this hopeful admonition ignores the glaring fact that America’s dysfunctional political turmoil is a cultural problem that is arising upstream from Washington D.C. Calling for a straightforward political fix to this pre-political problem, such as national leaders convening a new centrist party, ignores the cultural nature of the problem. Well meaning establishment centrists are thus looking for a solution to hyperpolarization in the wrong place. This is what is known as the “streetlight effect,” which Wikipedia illustrates with this well-known joke:

“A policeman sees a drunk man searching for something under a streetlight and asks what the drunk has lost. He says he lost his keys and they both look under the streetlight together. After a few minutes the policeman asks if he is sure he lost them here, and the drunk replies, no, and that he lost them in the park. The policeman asks why he is searching here, and the drunk replies, ‘this’ is where the light is’”

As long as we continue to look for solutions to our governmental gridlock within the confines of politics-as-usual we will be “looking for our keys” under the proverbial streetlight. As the Institute for Cultural Evolution has been arguing since its inception in 2013, hyperpolarization is not a problem that can be solved by conventional political strategies. The only way to ameliorate this “wicked problem” is to effectively grow out of it.

In response to this need for cultural maturation, my forthcoming book, Developmental Politics, describes a realistic yet inspiring “new politics of culture” through which America can grow into a less polarized version of itself. Although relatively complete, the publication of this book is still some time away. Yet as publication nears I will be sharing more of its ideas and generally preparing to launch the next phase of the Institute for Cultural Evolution’s political and cultural activism.

Please stay tuned, and thank you for your ongoing interest in our work.

— Steve McIntosh, ICE President

Comments are closed.

The Presence of the InfiniteThe Presence of the Infinite
brings new light to the important subject of spiritual experience, and the cultural leadership potential of evolutionary spirituality.
Evolution's PurposeEvolutionʼs Purpose
presents a fresh and compelling view of the scientific facts of evolution, and shows how a deeper understanding of evolution itself can lead directly to a more evolved world.
Integral ConsciousnessIntegral Consciousness
provides an accessible introduction to the power of the integral perspective, while also making a variety of original contributions in the application of integral philosophy to politics and spirituality.

Twitter Quotes

  • In order to overcome our divisions, we need to grow further. https://t.co/vT1F6s1bQs https://t.co/dhoHP0Cplc
  • Globalism and nationalism are ultimately interdependent https://t.co/x3TnxjTpie
Follow @McIntoshQuotes

Recent Posts

  • Backpacking in Big Bend National Park

  • Hyper-Partisan Polarization is More of a Cultural Problem than a Political One

  • 100 Miles on the Pacific Crest Trail in Oregon

    Join Email List

    Receive Steve’s Newsletters and Announcements

    Contact

    • steve@stevemcintosh.com
      • Youtube
      • Facebook
      • Twitter
      • Rss
    Wikipedia
    © 2018 Steve McIntosh